Is the Game P2W?

This web page lists many popular PC live service games and attempts to represent their monetization strategy in order to help gamers understand them before getting into the games. This web page does not take into consideration RMT* if it is against the game’s ToS* regardless of its level of enforcement.

Like a lot of things in life, being P2W isn’t black or white. Winning has a wide range of significations. It all depends on what your goals are as a player.
This is why this webpage is analysing 4 different categories of monetization incentives. Scroll to the bottom of the page for definitions and clarifications.

Many games in this list offer a free to play version of their game that have certain features locked behind a paywall of subscription. Any advantages of those subscriptions isn’t taken into consideration in the bellow tables as they are usually considered a fair P2P strategy by communities.

This web page is in constant evolution and may contain errors. Please feel free to send constructive feedback here: [email protected]
You can send modification requests or new game requests filling the form at the bottom of this page.

MMORPG

GameWebsitePay for BiS powerPay to progressPay for conveniencePay for cosmeticsFree to playSubscriptionComments
Albion OnlineLinkUnder analysisUnder analysisUnder analysisYesYesOptionnal but essential
Link
You can buy Gold and exchange it into Silver which makes you able to buy items from the marketplace or services from other players.
Black Desert OnlineLinkYesYesYesYesYesOptional but essential
Link
Possible to buy XP boosts but no skips.
Dungeons & Dragons OnlineLinkNoYesYesYesYesOptional but essential
Link
Possible to buy XP boosts but no skips.
Elder Scrolls OnlineLinkNo
YesNoYesNoOptional but essential
Link
Possible to buy XP boosts but no skips.

Possible to buy mules to get add. inventory space.
EVE onlineLinkYesYesYesYesYesOptional but essential
Link
Plex is a way to buy ISK for money which makes you able to buy items from the auction house or services from other players.
Final Fantasy XIV OnlineLinkNoYesNoYesFree up to level 60Yes
Guild Wars 2LinkYesYesYesYesYesNoGems are a way to buy gold for money which makes you able to buy items from the auction house or services from other players.
MIR4LinkYesYesYesYesYesOptional but essential
Link
Cryptocurrency mechanics
New WorldLinkNoNoNoYesNoNoA small amount of Umbral Shards (endgame BiS* resource) have dropped from Twitch Prime
Old School RunescapeLinkYesYesYesNoYesOptional but essential
Link
Bonds are a way to buy gold for money which makes you able to buy items from the auction house or services from other players.
Old School Runescape – IronmanLinkNoNoNoNoYesOptional but essential
Link
RuneScapeLinkYesYesYesYesYesOptional but essential
Link
Bonds are a way to buy gold for money which makes you able to buy items from the auction house or services from other players.
RuneScape – IronmanLinkNoNoNoNoYesOptional but essential
Link
Star Wars The Old RepublicLinkNoNoNoYesFree up to level 60Optional but essential
Link
The Lord of the Rings OnlineLinkNoYesYesYesFree up to level 95Optional but essential
Link
World of WarcraftLinkNoYesYesYesFree up to level 20YesThe WoW Token is a way to buy gold for money which makes you able to buy items from the auction house or services from other players.
World of Warcraft ClassicLinkNoNoNoNoNoYes
World of Warcraft WotLK ClassicLinkNoYesYesYesNoYesCosmetics limited to store mounts.
The WoW Token is a way to buy gold for money which makes you able to buy items from the auction house or services from other players.

Isometric ARPG

GameWebsitePay for BiS powerPay to progressPay for conveniencePay for cosmeticsFree to playSubscriptionComments
Diablo IILinkNoNoNoNoNoNo
Diablo IIILinkNoNoNoYesNoNoNot many cosmetics are offered.
Diablo ImmortalLinkYesNoNoYesYesNoLottery mechanisms
Diablo IVLinkNoNoNoYesNoNoPossible to pay to progress inside battle pass. However, any non-cosmetic items are locked behind a level requirement.
Grim DawnLinkNoNoNoYesNoNoNot many cosmetics are offered.
Last EpochLinkNoNoNoYesNoNo
Lost ArkLinkYesYesYesYesYesOptional but essential
Link
Lottery mechanisms
Path of ExileLinkNoNoYesYesYesNoPay for convenience is capped and objectively low cost.
Torchlight 2LinkNoNoNoNoNoNo
Torchlight 3LinkNoNoNoNoNoNoGame switched monetization strategy after launch
Torchlight InfiniteLinkYesNoYesYesYesNoLottery mechanisms
V RisingLinkNoNoNoYesNoNo
Wolcen: Lords of MayhemLinkNoNoNoNoNoNo

FPS

GameWebsitePay for BiS powerPay to progressPay for conveniencePay for cosmeticsFree to playSubscriptionComments
Overwatch 2LinkNoNoNoYesYesNo
Call of DutyLinkNoYesNoYesNoNo
Call of Duty: WarzoneLinkNoYesNoYesYesNo
Counter-Strike: Global OffensiveLinkNoNoNoYesYesNoLottery mechanisms
PUBG: BATTLEGROUNDSLinkNoYesNoYesYesOptional
APEX LegendsLinkNoYesNoYesYesNo
Team Fortress 2LinkNoNoNoYesYesNo
Tom Clancy’s Rainbow Six SiegeLinkNoYesNoYesNoNoLottery mechanisms

You can pay for characters. It is debatable wheter or not that makes it Pay for BiS power as balance between characters change constantly.
Destiny 2LinkNoYesNoYesNoNoBattle pass contains BiS resources and can be paid to progress faster.
ValorantLinkNoYesNoYesYesNo

MOBA

GameWebsitePay for BiS powerPay to progressPay for conveniencePay for cosmeticsFree to playSubscriptionComments
Dota 2LinkNoNoNoYesYesNo
League of LegendsLinkNoNoNoYesYesNoYou can pay for characters and runes. It is debatable wheter or not that makes it Pay for BiS power as balance between characters change constantly.
SMITELinkNoNoNoYesYesNoYou can pay for characters. It is debatable wheter or not that makes it Pay for BiS power as balance between characters change constantly.

RTS

GameWebsitePay for BiS powerPay to progressPay for conveniencePay for cosmeticsFree to playSubscriptionComments
StarCraft IILinkNoNoNoYesNoNo
StarCraft RemasteredLinkNoNoNoNoNoNo

Definitions

** Caveats to many of these will be explained in the “Comments” column of each game.
Pay for BiS power = Being able to directly or indirectly pay real money for in-game BiS* items or consumables that increases overall power in PvP/PvE.
Pay to progress = Being able to directly or indirectly pay real money for in-game achievements, leveling or content skip/acceleration.
Pay for convenience = Being able to directly or indirectly pay real money for in-game QoL* improvements regardless of its effect on power or progress.
Pay for cosmetics = Being able to directly or indirectly pay real money for in-game aesthetics of any sort that do not affect any of the above mentionned categories.
Free to play = A usually watered-down version of the game is available for free. Free trial means that some content is locked behind a paywall.

Pay for BiS power = This may reduce a player’s feeling of accomplishment upon acquiring BiS gear for his/her character or reaching endgame milestones such as defeating an enemy.
Pay to progress = This may reduce a player’s feeling of accomplishment upon leveling a character to max level or acquiring certain archievements.
Pay for convenience = This may frustrate a player that has to spend extra time or work doing an activity that could be facilitated behind a paywall.
Pay for cosmetics = This may reduce a player’s feeling of pride in having a good looking character, accessories or creatures.

MMORPG = Massively Multiplayer Online Role-Playing Game
ARPG = Action Role-Playing Game
FPS = First Person Shooter
MOBA = Multiplayer Online Battle Arena
RTS = Real Time Strategy

ToS = Terms of Service
BiS = Best in Slot
QoL = Quality of Life
RMT = Real Money Trading

Add/modify a game

Please enable JavaScript in your browser to complete this form.
Being able to directly or indirectly pay real money for in-game BiS* items or consumables that increases overall power in PvP/PvE.
Being able to directly or indirectly pay real money for in-game achievements, leveling or content skip/acceleration.
Being able to directly or indirectly pay real money for in-game QoL* improvements regardless of its effect on power or progress.
Being able to directly or indirectly pay real money for in-game aesthetics of any sort that do not affect any of the above mentionned categories.
Add caveats to the above mentionned. Explain your reasoning and provide examples if possible.